Discovering My Link to The Old Stone House

My mother inspired an interest in genealogy by leaving handwritten notes about our ancestors. One note said my great-grandfather Ira Whitcomb (1855-1928) was born “near Cov. Ky. In the Old Stonewall House (once a tavern).”

Mother’s note about Stonewall House in Covington, KY Source: Author’s Collection

So, why was Ira born there and where was it located? Over two decades after finding the note, I would find out.

Search for Answers Begins in a Cemetery

Dinah’s prone headstone; script eroding Source: Author’s Collection

One of Ira’s ancestors was his great-great grandmother and my fifth great-grandmother, Dinah Davis Piersol Kennedy (1735-1821). Her grave lays in Historic Linden Grove Cemetery and Arboretum in Covington, Kentucky. In the fall of 2020, I went to see it.

A 2012 photo from Find-A-Grave showed Dinah’s upright headstone1 and served as a guide. It took thirty minutes of searching to find it. But now, it was no longer upright. Her headstone laid horizontal on the ground with grass growing up around it. Weather and time had eroded the script, making it barely legible. A few more years and her name on this memorial would fade away. I snapped a photo and left. The gray sky matched my melancholy mood as I drove home.

Over the next year, I researched Dinah’s life. Her American roots were in Pennsylvania. English Quaker William Penn founded Pennsylvania in 1682 as a refuge for Quakers and other persecuted people. Pennsylvania’s reputation for tolerance and cheap, plentiful land attracted waves of emigrants. They came from Wales, Ireland, and many other countries.

Dinah’s paternal grandfather was Jenkin Davies (1675-1748). He emigrated to Pennsylvania’s Welsh Tract in the early 1700s from the County of Cardigan, Wales. Jenkin acquired land in Radnor Township and later one thousand acres in Earl Township. When he died, he willed four hundred acres in Earl Township to his son Zaccheus Davis (1710-1788). Zaccheus and daughter Dinah were first- and second-generation Americans.

1687 Map showing the Welch Tract that included Radnor Township in Chester County and Earl Township. Holme, Thomas, -1695, John Harris, and Philip Lea. A mapp of ye improved part of Pensilvania in America, divided into countyes, townships, and lotts. [London?: s.n., ?, 1687] Map. Retrieved from the Library of Congress.

 Around 1753, eighteen-year-old Dinah married John Piersol (1720-1765). He is my fifth great-grandfather and fourth-generation American. John’s great-great-grandfather, Thomas Pearsall (Bef.1593-1642) was English. He managed the family tobacco business in England, Holland, and Virginia from the early to mid-1600s, settling in Virginia later than 1630. After twelve years of marriage, John died in 1765, leaving Dinah a widow with three young children.

Dinah Has a Suitor

Accounts describe thirty-three-year-old widow Dinah as comely. She caught the attention of twenty-seven-year-old Thomas Kennedy, Jr. (1741-1821). He proposed marriage, but there was an obstacle to overcome-Thomas Kennedy, Sr. (1703-1789). Thomas Sr. emigrated to America from Northern Ireland before 1730. Between 1700 and 1775 over 200,000 Presbyterians, including Thomas, Sr., fled Northern Ireland. They came to America to escape religious discrimination and collapsing economic conditions.2

Thomas, Sr., settled on a farm by the Brandywine River in Chester County, Pennsylvania. He became wealthy by extending interest-bearing loans in gold. An outgoing man, he enjoyed singing songs and telling jokes and stories.

With first wife Margaret (17xx-xxxx), Thomas, Sr. had at least two children–Thomas, Jr. and Margaret. After his wife’s death and in his mid-sixties, Thomas, Sr., married Ann Kilbreath (17xx-xxxx). According to Ann, Thomas, Sr. cantered down the road on his gray mare to court her, leaping the mare over each gate on the way.

The lively Thomas Sr. was a devout Presbyterian who planned for his son to be a minister. He objected to Thomas marrying Dinah, this widow with three children and six years older than his son. To stop the marriage, Thomas Sr. arranged to send Thomas to Ireland. But Thomas and Dinah foiled his plan by eloping to nearby Philadelphia. They married on October 28, 1767, and by 1773 had three children.

The Revolutionary War Changes Lives

When the Revolutionary War began in 1775, it disrupted Thomas and Dinah’s life. Thomas and other family members were patriots. Thomas served as a Private in the First Pennsylvania Continental Line.3 Records show that Dinah’s father, brother, son, and son-in-law served too. It must have been stressful for Dinah-worrying about the men’s safety, caring for her three young children, and taking on Thomas’s responsibilities while he served.

A major battle took place in Chester County, where Thomas and Dinah lived. On September 11, 1777, at The Battle of Brandywine, 11,000 Continentals faced 18,000 British troops. In the morning fog, British Generals Howe and Cornwallis used the poor visibility to outmaneuver the Patriots. They split their men into two sections and moved to surround General Washington’s soldiers. Caught by surprise, Washington understood the British troops outnumbered his men and nearly surrounded them. He ordered a retreat. Although it was a patriot defeat, the British gained little.4

The war ended in 1783 with America’s independence from England. Many people found their fortunes reduced. They began rebuilding their lives or moving west to start anew. Post-war, Thomas Sr.’s creditors began repaying him with Continental script, and he objected.

Example of script used in Pennsylvania
By National Museum of American History – Source: Image by Godot13, Public Domain

Thomas Sr. believed they should repay him in gold, and often hid instead of accepting their continentals. He said that would be “taking bad money for good money.” He was right-the continentals became worthless.

In 1789 Thomas Sr. died. Thomas’s father left him the principal from bonds and creditors’ notes. That year, Thomas bought two hundred acres in Kentucky for 150 pounds. The previous year, when Dinah’s father died, he willed her sixty pounds. Perhaps the couples’ inherited money made the buy possible.

How Thomas Bought “The Point”

The land Thomas bought in Kentucky, known as The Point, lay where the Licking River joins the Ohio. There are several accounts of how Thomas gained the land. One colorful version claims Virginian George Muse, a war veteran, received the two-hundred-acre land grant for his service. Muse swapped the grant for a keg of whiskey. The new owner turned around and traded it for a quarter of a buffalo. Apparently, the prospect of a keg of whisky or a quarter of buffalo appealed to them more than locating and settling two hundred acres.

Next, the grant became the property of Stephen Trigg, who surveyed and patented the land. Trigg then sold it to James Welch. For reasons unknown, Welch wound up in jail in Pennsylvania. After hearing about the land, Thomas visited Welch in jail and made an offer. At the same time, John Bartle was trying to locate Welch to buy the land, willing to pay four times what Thomas offered. But Bartle was too late. Thomas had closed the deal, owned the land, and immediately made plans to settle there.

West To Kentucky

In 1790, as Thomas and Dinah prepared to move west to Kentucky, he was 49, and she was 55. All their children would join them except Dinah’s son Zaccheus Piersol, thirty-six, (1754-1804). Going west were Thomas and Dinah’s children Joseph Kennedy, twenty-two (1768-1825), Samuel Kennedy, twenty (1770-1831), Hannah Kennedy, seventeen (1773-1816), Dinah’s daughter, Sarah Sallie Piersol, thirty-five (1755-1838) and her husband Robert Kyle, thirty-nine (1751-1825), and Dinah’s daughter, Mary Piersol, thirty-three (1757-xxxx). Sallie and Robert would bring their five children, all under ten. And Sallie was pregnant.

We have no records telling of their preparation and journey, but we can imagine both. The trip before them required crossing the rugged landscape of the Allegheny Mountains to the Ohio River, and then traveling down river to The Point in Kentucky. Likely Thomas felt reassured having three young men along.

Painting by Newbold Hough Trotter (1827-1898), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

A group their size required outfitting two or three Conestoga wagons. These wagons originated in Pennsylvania’s Lancaster County in the mid-1700s. The designers made them to haul up to six tons of goods over rough roads. The Conestoga wagon’s floor curved up at each end to prevent contents from falling out, canvas covers arched over wooden hoops, and a gate at the end held in place by a chain could drop for loading and unloading. Four to six horses pulled each wagon.5

As they loaded their wagons, they took only what was necessary-provisions for themselves and their horses, implements for farming and cooking, minimal clothing, guns, and ammunition.

Crossing the Alleghenies

Earlier settlers followed trails made over centuries by Native Americans. Thomas’s family traveled via the Forbes Road. The British constructed this road during the French and Indian War to move troops and supplies over the Alleghenies to Fort Pitt (current day Pittsburgh).6

On the road, the family faced daily challenges. Thomas, Dinah, and the rest walked alongside the wagon, rode a horse behind the wagon, or sat on a lazy board-a ledge of wood pulled out from under the bed of the wagon and placed in front of the rear wheels.7 Maybe the older children ran back and forth while the adults found the daily trek difficult. The women surely shared caring for the children and kept an eye on their safety.

Most likely they dealt with potentially disastrous difficulties–harsh weather, illness, getting stuck in mud, wagon wheels breaking, or attacks by other travelers.

Down the Ohio River by Flatboat

It took the family up to six weeks to reach the Upper Ohio Valley. Once there, they secured a flatboat. Many enterprising people built and sold flatboats to the thousands of settlers migrating west.8

Engraving by Alfred Waud from The Historic New Orleans Collection.
 Source: Public Domain

Their rectangular, flat-bottomed boat measured as much as fifty-five feet long by sixteen feet wide. They navigated downstream using long sweeps on the sides, a steering oar, and a short front sweep. A shed in the rear housed livestock, and a cabin forward provided shelter for the family.9

Even if their river journey was less strenuous than crossing the mountains, it wasn’t easy. Supervising five children on a flatboat demanded constant vigilance. Encountering rocks, debris, rapids, or sandbars could be catastrophic. The threat of attack by river pirates and Native Americans was real. Their flatboat resembled a floating fort. It had one heavily barred door and small windows with sliding shutters. In case of an attack, they could fire guns through loopholes pierced in the walls.10

Life In Kentucky

Within a week, they arrived at their downstream destination, The Point. Thomas, Dinah, and their family became the first permanent settlers. The men took the flatboat apart for lumber and began building cabins and clearing the land.

The Point was straight across from Losantiville (now Cincinnati) on the Ohio side. Francis Kennedy (1746-1794), wife Rebekah (1755-1816), and seven children landed there the previous year. (Accounts refer to Francis as Thomas Kennedy’s brother, but it is unproven.) Francis operated the first ferry business from the Ohio side, and Thomas soon started his ferry business on the Kentucky side. He and Francis operated ferries across the Ohio and Licking Rivers carrying livestock, people, and wagons.

Hannah’s Ferry on the Yadkin River between Lavies and Rowan Counties ca. 1900. Source: North Carolina Office of Archives and History, Call #N-62-8-53.

Running the Ferry

There are strong currents in the Ohio and Licking Rivers. Oars alone could not guide ferries back and forth between the riverbanks. The ferrymen propelled the ferries using their physical strength and either poles or a rope system strung between landings. When a ferry arrived at the opposite shore, it ground to a stop. Drop down ramps on each end allowed loading and unloading.11

The militia traveled between Ohio and Kentucky on the ferries. Fort Washington, on the Ohio side, protected the settlers from Native American attacks. In 1794, Francis Kennedy drowned while ferrying cattle across the river for the army.

Operating the Kennedy Inn and Tavern 

That year, Thomas continued operating his ferry. He became a justice for the Campbell County Court and got a license to sell liquor. Thomas and Dinah opened Kennedy Inn and Tavern in their log cabin. (As early as 1787, the county set prices—whiskey, twelve shillings; warm dinner, one shilling, sixpence; breakfast or supper, one shilling; night’s lodging with a good feather bed and clean sheets, one shilling.)

The population was sparse. Even ten years later, the census shows only seventy-six residents in the area where the Kennedy’s lived (now Kenton County). People knew Thomas as a congenial host, welcoming travelers and newcomers. People arrived via raft or flatboat on the river and by oxen and cart over buffalo trails. They stopped, needing to resupply, or wanting to hear opinions about where to settle.

When Newport adopted its first charter on December 14, 1795, Thomas became one of Newport’s first trustees.

Building the Old Stone House

The Old Stone House. Source: Courtesy of Kenton County Library, KY.

By 1801, Thomas and Dinah replaced the cabin with The Old Stone House. The large home, including Kennedy Inn, overlooked the Licking River. It was all stone, with three-foot-thick exterior walls, a broad staircase, and beautiful woodwork. The stone outbuildings included a barn, springhouse, henhouse, and smokehouse.

In 1806, as traffic increased on the river, Thomas added a second ferry. Rates, likely set by the general assembly, were 1 ½ cents for small livestock, 6 ¼ cents for cattle and people, 12 ½ cents for a man on a horse, and fifty cents for a team and wagon. During the War of 1812, his ferry transported soldiers and supplies.

Thomas and Dinah enjoyed a prosperous life owning land, an inn and tavern, and two ferries. In November 1812, Thomas advertised 150 acres for sale. His original plat extended from the Ohio River to Sixth Street and from the Licking River to the west side of Johnson Street Licking River to the west side of Johnson Street.

City Atlas of Covington, Kentucky, Published by G.M. Hopkins, C.E., Philadelphia, 1877, pp. 10,11.

Establishing Covington, Kentucky

The 150-acre tract sold in 1814 to John S. Gano, Richard M. Gano and Thomas Carneal of the Covington Company for $50,000. On February 2, 1815, they chartered the town, naming it Covington after General Leonard Covington of Maryland. Covington was a hero of the War of 1812, who died of wounds received in the Battle of Chrysler’s Field.

Thomas and Dinah’s Final Years

Thomas still owned The Old Stone House and ferry landing. He and Dinah moved to Newport briefly. By 1816, they lived in a house Thomas built at the corner of Sixth and Greenup, later known as the Cooper House. Thomas was seventy-five and Dinah, eighty-one. Thomas’s oldest son Joseph ran the farm and ferry.

Dinah died on May 21, 1821. July 14, Thomas wrote his will and died on August 1. He left his living descendants bequeaths of roughly one thousand dollars each. His stepchildren received fifty dollars each. Thomas divided his property among his children; son Samuel’s share included The Old Stone House and the ferry.

The family buried Thomas and Dinah in the Craig Street Cemetery.12 When it fell into disrepair mid-century, the family re-interred Thomas and Dinah near other family members in Linden Grove Cemetery.

Fate of the Old Stone House

Samuel Kennedy died in 1831. He left The Old Stone House to his daughter, Nancy Kennedy (1811-1904). She lived there until 1847, when she built a larger, more up-to-date house right behind it. Nancy never married and maintained both homes throughout her life. She was known for her hospitality and generosity, even raising and educating her niece’s six orphaned children.13 The ferry stayed in the family too and continued operating until the Roebling Suspension bridge opened in 1867.  Then, in 1909, they tore down The Old Stone House.

Sketch from the steamboat landing in Cincinnati, 1836. The Old Stone House where Nancy Kennedy was living is to the right. The sketch is by D. J (?) Kennedy.    Courtesy of Northern Kentucky Views (from their Facebook page).

The Search Comes Full Circle

Source: Author’s Collection

Finally, I knew my great-grandfather Ira Whitcomb’s connection to the Old Stonewall house.

It was the fall of 2021. The past year of research revealed Dinah’s story. I wanted her life to be remembered and contacted Linden Grove’s Superintendent Rick Ludlum to ask about restoring Dinah’s headstone. He located it and then found Thomas Kennedy, Jr.’s headstone laying prone near hers.

It turns out Dinah and Thomas have historical significance for Linden Grove. A plaque at the cemetery entrance acknowledges Thomas as the original landowner of Covington, and Dinah and Thomas’s death dates are the oldest in the cemetery.

Linden Grove’s board approved the restorations. Superintendent Rick Ludlum restored both headstones, built bases, and poured concrete footers at the burial sites. Last, Rick attached the bronze plaques my sister and I bought for each headstone.

Gravestones for Thomas and Dinah Kennedy Source: Author’s Collection

Prologue

Today George Rogers Clark Park sits at the corner of Garrard and Riverside Drive-the site of The Old Stone House. A monument and plaque commemorate the house and Thomas Kennedy’s history.

A short walk along Riverside Drive to the west, the Roebling Suspension Bridge spans the Ohio River.

A flood wall on the Covington side displays the Roebling Murals-eighteen scenes depicting the history of the area from 8000 B.C. to the current time. It includes a mural of the Kennedy Ferry crossing the Ohio River.

End Notes

1Find a Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/43800665/dinah-kennedy: accessed 22 November 2021), memorial page for Dinah Davis Kennedy (12 Oct 1735-21 May 1821), Find a Grave Memorial ID 43800665, citing Linden Grove Cemetery, Covington, Kenton County, Kentucky, USA; Maintained by T. Morgan (contributor 47082858).

2Shannon, Dr. Catherine B., Irish Immigration to American, 1630 to 1921. (on line) www.nantucketatheneum.org/wp-content/uploads/Irish-Immigration-to-America.pdf., accessed 16 Feb, 2022.

3 Lineage Book of the Charter Members of the DAR Vol 047, p.198, 46438; Ancestry.com. North America, Family Histories, 1500-2000 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2016.

4“The Battle of Brandywine begins,” History, A&E Publishing Networks, Nov 13, 2009, last update Sept 9, 2020, https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/the-battle-of-brandywine-begins, accessed 4 May 2022.

5“Conestoga Wagon,” History, A&E Television Network, April 5, 2010, last updated August 21, 2018,https://www.history.com/topics/westward-expansion/conestoga-wagon , accessed April 17, 2022.

6ExplorePAhistory.com, Stories from PA History, Crossing the Alleghenies, online https://explorepahistory.com/story.php?storyId=1-9-A&chapter=0; accessed 7 Feb 2022.

7“Conestoga Wagon,”

8Did You Know Boats, “Flatboats,” online https://didyouknowboats.com/flatboats/ ; accessed May 5, 2022.

9IBID

10IBID

11 “Ferryboats of Colonial America,” Harry Schenawolf, online https://www.revolutionarywarjournal.com/ferry-boats-of-colonial-america/, December 11, 2019, accesses May 5, 2022.

12In the 1870s, the city of Covington bought a lot at the new Highland Cemetery in Fort Mitchell, dedicated to the Pioneers of Covington. They moved most of the bodies from the Craig Street Cemetery and some to Linden Grove.

13Historical records describe Nancy Kennedy moving in a literary circle. Harriet Beecher Stowe was a guest. Accounts say she wrote the introduction to Uncle Tom’s Cabin while staying with Nancy. The English author, Anthony Trollope, was another visitor. Just as interesting, when Nancy’s niece and husband died during a cholera outbreak, Nancy stepped in to raise and educate their six orphaned children. One child, Louise Southgate, had a distinguished career as the first female doctor in the area and promoted women’s suffrage.

Sources

Jenkin Davies

Ancestry.com. Biographical annals of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania [database on-line]. Provo, UT: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2005. Original data: Biographical annals of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, containing biographical and genealogical sketches of prominent and representative citizens and of many of the early settlers.. Chicago: J.H. Beers & Co., 1903.

Piersol (Pearsall)

Ancestry.com. History and genealogy of the Pearsall family in England and America [database on-line]. Provo, UT: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2005.

Original data: Pearsall, Clarence E.,. History and genealogy of the Pearsall family in England and America. San Francisco: H.S. Crocker, 1928.

Kennedy

Kennedy, Thomas Howell, Family History of the Thomas Kennedy Family, Joseph Kennedy Branch: Thomas Kennedy Senior, ca. 1910 (transcribed from a typewritten copy); Ancestry.com entry (on-line), 19 Nov, 2011 by portola81, accessed 19 Feb 2022.

Bricking, Chuck, Covington Heritage, 1980, Northern Kentucky Views (on-line),

http://www.nkyviews.com/kenton/pdf/bricking_kennedy.pdf

R. Dorsey, A Gist Historical Society Paper, Thomas Kennedy, Founder of Covington, Kentucky, August 24, 1954, online www.nkyviews .

Johnson, E., History of Kentucky and Kentuckians: The Leaders and Representative Men in Commerce, Industry and Modern Activities, Thomas Kennedy, pp. 908-909, Lewis Publishing Company; Original from the New York Public Library; Digitized Feb 11, 2008.

Encyclopedia of Northern Kentucky, Chapter K, Thomas Kennedy.

About the author

Deborah Oliver, a retired Human Resources professional, lives in Nancy, Kentucky, on Lake Cumberland with her husband Bob. Before moving to Nancy in 2014, they lived in Cincinnati, Ohio. They have two sons and three grandsons. She developed her interest in genealogy as a retirement avocation. Other interests include reading, gardening, backyard birdwatching, and spending time with friends and family.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.